← All posts

Selling Through an OTA? You Just Lost Your Line to the Guest

By

TL;DR: A one-star review landed on us. It belonged to a different operator. I checked our side anyway and found a real gap: when we started selling through an OTA this season, those guests stopped getting our pre-tour information. Now a team member on our sales team messages them in the platform chat right away, with an infographic and a short video. For any operator adding an OTA channel, the lesson fits in one line from the original: "The platform sells the tour. Preparing the guest is still our job."

Read the original on Kay Tours: The One-Star Review Wasn't Meant for Us. The Lesson Was.

A correction isn't the end of the story

In July I wrote on the Kay Tours blog about a one-star review on our whale shark tour, and about why we over-communicate with guests. Later I learned the review had landed on us by mistake.

I told the story in public. So I corrected it in public.

That could have been the end. Wrong company, not our review, move on. But the review had already sent me into the reservation. What I found there was mine to own.

Audit your own side first

My habit when a bad review comes in: open the booking and check what we actually told the guest before the tour.

For this one, the honest answer was very little.

Direct bookings, which reach us by email, have always gotten pre-tour preparation from us. That process worked. But this season was the first time we sold through an online travel agency. And this reservation was our first whale shark booking of the season through that channel.

Our process assumed we owned the conversation with the guest. On the new channel, we didn't.

What an OTA takes from the operator

This is what I'd want every operator to know before switching on an OTA listing.

You lose most of your communication layer. No confirmation from you. No pre-tour emails from you. Your one direct line is the chat inside the platform. Most guests never look at it.

So the guest shows up with whatever the listing told them. For a day inside a federally protected biosphere reserve, where seasickness is a real concern, that isn't enough.

The review wasn't about us. The gap was. I own that.

Rebuilding pre-tour prep inside the platform chat

We stopped waiting for guests to come to us.

When a booking arrives through a booking website, a team member on our sales team writes to the guest through the platform chat right away. That welcome message carries everything needed for the day. Two things go with it:

  • An infographic of the full day. The schedule hour by hour, seasickness prep, what to pack and what to leave, and how we work inside the reserve. I built it with a few AI tools.
  • A three-minute explainer video. For guests who prefer watching. You'll find it on our YouTube channel and website.

Guests who book with us directly see both on the booking page.

The result so far: since late June, no negative feedback on those bookings.

For operators, the point is this. If the platform owns the channel, use the one channel it leaves you. And use it the moment the booking lands.

Being invisible has a price

Being hard to reach isn't only a guest-experience problem. It has a number attached.

Booking websites keep roughly 25 to 35-plus percent of what the guest pays as commission. I run our products, so I look at these figures every day. Each platform sets a per-tour minimum that depends on value and demand. Our floor on one of the largest is 24.6 percent, and there's no way under it. Some high-demand tours can't go below 37 percent.

I'm not against OTAs. Travelers trust the reviews there, and I'd read them too. But operators pay a lot for that reach. And in return, they often lose the direct line to the guest.

Inventory is easy to sell. Experiences are built by local teams. Those teams should be visible, and they need a real way to reach guests before the tour, not after a bad review.

What I'd pass on to other operators

  • When a bad review hits, check your own side before you decide it isn't yours.
  • Every new sales channel needs its own pre-tour plan. Don't assume your direct-booking process carries over.
  • Know what each channel costs you, and what you give up for it.

A mistake that wasn't ours showed me one that was. Better to find it this way than to hear it from a guest who showed up unprepared.

FAQ

Was the one-star review about Kay Tours? No. It reached us by mistake. The guest meant to review a different operator.

Then why change anything? Because checking it exposed a real gap. Guests who booked through a booking website weren't getting our pre-tour information. Direct-booking guests were.

How do OTA bookings limit an operator? The operator can't send its own confirmation or pre-tour emails. The only direct channel is the platform chat, which most guests never open.

What do OTA guests get from Kay Tours now? A welcome message in the platform chat from a team member on our sales team, plus a full-day infographic and a three-minute explainer video.

How much commission do booking websites take? Roughly 25 to 35-plus percent. On one large platform, our lowest possible rate is 24.6 percent, and some high-demand tours have a 37 percent minimum.