← All posts

Which Parts of a Tour Business Should Stay Human?

By Build Log

TL;DR: Not the logins. The guides, and how they talk with guests on tours, should stay human. My bots tried to keep a booking-platform session alive, and it failed. I was annoyed. If I tell them to, they can look for a workaround.

What got built

  • Nothing new shipped on the tour side. It was a light day.
  • Routine morning monitoring ran: competitor prices and promos, reviews, weather, ports, sargassum and industry news.
  • Two analytics jobs caught up in the afternoon after a morning connector outage.

Why this question came up

The bots tried a fix for the booking bot. It made gentle clicks every 90 minutes to keep the admin session alive. It didn't work. The session still expired after about 24 hours. The best guess is a hard limit on the platform's side. That is not confirmed.

So the ops bot couldn't do its morning review. The one thing it needed from me was a sign-in. It asked once and didn't keep nagging. At the end of the day, that sign-in was still pending.

I was annoyed. But I don't think a daily login is something that has to stay human. If I instruct the bots, they can find a workaround.

What should stay human is different. At my tour company in Cancún, that's the guides' interaction with guests on tours. A bot can watch prices and weather.

What changed technically

  • Keepalive clicks every 90 minutes didn't extend the session. It still ended after about 24 hours.
  • A connector outage held two analytics jobs in the morning. They caught up in the afternoon.
  • Market research: no competitor price or promo changes on the pages the bot could load. Some review sites block automated reads. No negative reviews. Some small-craft ports were closed, there was rain, and sargassum was very low.
  • Industry news: PhocusWire reports that some tour operators are getting fewer bookings from big booking sites, and suspect travelers are asking AI chatbots and booking direct. One operator's bookings from a booking site fell almost 35% year over year, even as his overall sales grew. Another was offered more visibility if he raised his commission from 25% to 30%.

For my tour company, that means a focus on GEO, and better visibility and transparency (the trust problem I wrote about in why travelers don't trust tour operators). That includes our tour pages, with prices and what's included.

Side projects

  • An agency side project had 304 raw visits on Oct 20. After cleaning, 0 were real humans. The rest was internal traffic, me, bots and automation. The one booking-button click was me testing. I'm starting to trust the data more.
  • On the agency side project, the analytics connector couldn't issue a token in the morning, and the backup access didn't have the read rights it needed. So there was no second way in.
  • A five-variant test has 0 real sessions so far. The 20-session threshold is far off.
  • QA flagged empty test logging. The builder checked, and it wasn't a bug. It was only its own test runs, cleared after deploys. No data was lost, and a pointless deploy was avoided. Have I ever patched something in my business that wasn't broken? Not that I know of.
  • On a printables side project, one product went up for review. A redesign of another is in review with the design bot. I rated the last version at about 15% of what I expected. It was a very basic, mediocre design. Literally stick figures.

What I'd do differently

Have a second route to the data. On the agency side project, one auth problem stalled the morning, and the backup access didn't have the right permissions. That's still open.

Also open: my sign-in to the booking platform. On the side projects: my verdicts on three printable products and a messaging-channel business verification that's still waiting on the platform.

FAQ

Should a bot handle a daily login? Yes, if I tell it to find a workaround. A login doesn't need a human; guests do.

What stays human on purpose? The guides' interaction with guests on tours.

Why did 304 visits become 0? After cleaning, all 304 Oct 20 visits were internal traffic, me, bots or automation. Zero is a real answer.